Mental Health and Mental Health Courts

Mental health courts connect defendants with mental health problems with appropriate treatment and support resources within the community and seek to promote their engagement in the treatment programs. Proper assessment of participants' needs and the development of a treatment plan accordingly are features of these programs. Mental health court participants often also have related problems such as homelessness and substance abuse problems.


Queensland Mental Health Court
South Australia: Magistrates Court: Treatment Intervention Court
Tasmania: Magistrates Court of Tasmania Diversion List
Victoria: Assessment and Referral Court List, Magistrates Court of Victoria
Western Australia: Mental Health Court Diversion Program

Albalawi O et al, ‘Court diversion for those with psychosis and its impact on re-offending rates: results from a longitudinal data-linkage study’ (2019) 5(1) BJPsych Open 1-9

Allan A, 'The Past, Present and Future of Mental Health Law: A Therapeutic Jurisprudence Analysis' (2003) 20(2) Law in Context 24.

Beaupert F and Vernon A, 'Odyssey of hope': the role of carers in mental health tribunal processes and systems of mental health care’ (2011) 18(1) Psychiatry, Psychology and Law 44.

Bogdanoski T, 'Psychiatric Advance Directives: The New Frontier in Mental Health Law Reform in Australia?' 16 Journal of Law and Medicine 891.

Burville M, Dusmohamed S, Hunter N and McRostie H, 'The Management of Mentally Impaired Offenders Through the South Australian Criminal Justice System' (2003) International Journal of Law & Psychiatry 13.

Cannon A, Doley R, Ferguson C and Brooks N, 'Antisocial personality disorder and therapeutic justice court programs' (2012) 22 Journal of Judicial Administration 99, also available at:

Carne J, 'The Unimportance of M'Naghten's: What Happened to Therapeutic Jurisprudence?' (2003) 15(11) Judicial Officers' Bulletin 91.

Carney T, Tait D, Chappell D and Beaupert F, 'Mental Health Tribunals: 'TJ' Implications of Weighing Fairness, Freedom, Protection and Treatment' (2007) 17 Journal of Judicial Administration 46.

Carney T and Tait D, ‘Mental health tribunals - rights, protection, or treatment? Lessons from the ARC linkage grant study?’ (2011) 18(1) Psychiatry, Psychology and Law 137.

Davidson F, Heffernan E, Greenberg D, Waterworth R and Burgess P, ‘Mental Health and Criminal Charges: Variation in Diversion Pathways in Australia’ (2017) 24(6) Psychiatry, Psychology and Law 888

Diesfeld K and Freckelton I (eds), Involuntary Detention and Therapeutic Jurisprudence (Ashgate Publishing, 2003).

Diesfeld K and McKenna B, 'The Unintended Impact of the Therapeutic Intentions of the New Zealand Mental Health Review Tribunal : Therapeutic Jurisprudence Perspectives' (2007) 14 Law and Medicine 566.

Edgely M, ‘Solution-Focused Court Programs for Mentally Impaired Offenders: What Works?’ (2013) 22 Journal of Judicial Administration 207.

Edgely M, ‘Why do Mental Health Courts Work? A Confluence of Treatment, Support and Adroit Judicial Supervision’ (2014) 37 International Journal of Law & Psychiatry 572.

Edgely M, ‘Addressing the solution-focused sceptics: Moving beyond Punitivity in the sentencing of drug-addicted and mentally impaired offenders’ (2016) 39(1) University of New South Wales Law Journal 206-233

Freckelton I, ‘Mental Health Review Tribunal Decision-making: A Therapeutic Jurisprudence Lens’ (2003) 10(1) Psychiatry, Psychology and Law 44.

Graham H, A Foot in the (Revolving) Door? A Preliminary Evaluation of Tasmania's Mental Health Diversion List (University of Tasmania, 2007).

Hill M, 'Hobart Magistrates Court's mental health diversion list' (Tasmania) (2009) 18(3) Journal of Judicial Administration 178.

Lim L and Day A, 'Mental Health Diversion Courts: Some Directions for Further Development' (2013) 20(1) Psychiatry, Psychology and Law 36-45.

Lim L and Day A, 'Mental Health Diversion Courts: A Two Year Recidivism Study of a South Australian Mental Health Court Program' (2014) 32(4) Behavioral Sciences & the Law 539-551.

Lim L and Day A, 'An examination of stakeholder attitudes and understanding of therapeutic jurisprudence in a mental health court' (2016) 46 International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 27-34.

Lim L and Day A, 'Mental health diversion courts: A prospective study of reoffending and clinical outcomes of an Australian mental health court program' (2016) 55(4) Journal of Offender Rehabilitation 254-270.

Newitt E and Stojcevski V, Mental health diversion list evaluation report (Hobart, Tas: Magistrates Court Tasmania, 2009)

Popovic J, 'Meaningful v Meaningless Sentences: Sentencing the Unsentenceable' Paper presented to the 'Sentencing: Principles, Perspectives and Possibilities' conference, Canberra, 10-12 February 2006.

Purser K, Magner ES and Madison J, 'Competency and Capacity: The Legal and Medical Interface' (2009) 16 Journal of Law and Medicine 789.

Purser K, Magner Eilis S, Madison J, ‘A therapeutic approach to assessing legal capacity in Australia’ (2015) 38 International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 18.

Richardson E, 'Mental health courts: Access to justice for people with mental illness and cognitive impairments' (2019) Alternative Law Journal (in press).

Richardson E and McSherry B, 'Diversion Down Under: Programs for Offenders with Mental Illness in Australia' (2010) 33(4) International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 249.

Ross S and Graham J, ‘Screening offenders for health and mental health problems at court’ (2012) 19(1) Psychiatry, Psychology and Law 75.

Skrzypiec G, Wundersitz J and McRostie H, Magistrates Court Diversion Program: An Analysis of Post-Program Offending (OSCAR 2004)

Soon YL et al, ‘Mentally ill offenders eligible for diversion at local court in New South Wales (NSW), Australia: factors associated with initially successful diversion’ (2018) 29(5) Journal of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology 1-12

Smith A and Caple A, ‘Transparency in mental health: why mental health tribunals should be required to publish reasons’ (2014) 21(4) Journal of Law and Medicine 942.

Toki V, ‘Therapeutic jurisprudence and mental health courts for Maori’ (2010) 33(5-6) International journal of law and psychiatry 440.

Topp V, Thomas M and Ingvarson M, Lacking Insight: Involuntary Patient Experience of the Victorian Mental Health Review Board (Mental Health Legal Centre, 2008).

Walsh T, 'The Queensland Special Circumstances Court' (2007) 16 Journal of Judicial Administration 223.

Waterworth R, ‘The New Mental Health Act 2016 (QLD): An Evaluation of the Impact on Mental Health Clients in the Magistrate's Courts’ (2017) International Journal of Therapeutic Jurisprudence 195.

Weller P, ‘Taking a Reflexive Turn: Non-Adversarial Justice and Mental Health Tribunals’ (2011) 37 Monash University Law Review 81.

Zafirakis E, 'Curbing the "Revolving Door" Phenomenon with Mentally Impaired Offenders: Applying a Therapeutic Jurisprudence Lens' (2010) 20 Journal of Judicial Administration 81.